Search This Blog

Friday, December 31, 2010

4G is a myth (and a confusing mess)

chart_is_it_4g_v2.top.gif By David Goldman, staff writer


NEW YORK (CNNMoney.com) -- You've seen the 4G advertisements from T-Mobile, Sprint and Verizon, bragging about a much-better wireless network with blazing fast speeds.
Here's the secret the carriers don't advertise: 4G is a myth. Like the unicorn, it hasn't been spotted anywhere in the wild just yet -- and won't be any time in the near future.
The International Telecommunication Union, the global wireless standards-setting organization, determined last month that 4G is defined as a network capable of download speeds of 100 megabits per second (Mbps). That's fast enough to download an average high-definition movie in about three minutes.
None of the new networks the carriers are rolling out meet that standard.
Sprint (S, Fortune 500) was the first to launch a network called 4G, going live with it earlier this year. Then, T-Mobile launched its 4G network, claiming to be "America's largest 4G network." Verizon (VZ, Fortune 500) plans to launch its 4G network next week, which it claims will be the nation's largest and the fastest. AT&T (T, Fortune 500) is expected to unveil its 4G network next year.
Those networks have theoretical speeds of a fifth to a half that of the official 4G standard. The actual speeds the carriers say they'll achieve are just a tenth of "real" 4G.
So why are the carriers calling these networks 4G?
It's mostly a matter of PR, industry experts say. Explaining what the wireless carriers' new networks should be called, and what they'll be capable of, is a confusing mess.
To illustrate: Sprint bought a majority stake in Clearwire (CLWR), which uses a new network technology called WiMAX that's capable of speeds ranging from 3 Mbps to 10 Mbps. That's a different technology from Verizon's new network, based on a standard called Long Term Evolution (LTE), which will average 5 Mbps to 12 Mbps.
Seeing what its competitors were up to, T-Mobile opted to increase the speed capabilities of its existing 3G-HSPA+ network instead of pursuing a new technology. Its expanded network -- now called 4G -- will reach speeds of 5 Mbps to 12 Mbps.
No matter what they're called, all of these upgrades are clear improvements -- and the carriers shelled out billions to make them. Current "3G" networks offer actual speeds that range from between 500 kilobits per second to 1.5 Mbps.
So Sprint and Verizon have new, faster networks that are still technically not 4G, while T-Mobile has an old, though still faster network that is actually based on 3G technology.
Confused yet? That's why they all just opted to call themselves "4G."
The carriers get defensive about the topic.
"It's very misleading to make a decision about what's 4G based on speed alone," said Stephanie Vinge-Walsh, spokeswoman for Sprint Nextel. "It is a challenge we face in an extremely competitive industry."
T-Mobile did not respond to a request for comment.
One network representative, who asked not to be identified, claimed that ITU's 4G line-in-the-sand is being misconstrued. The organization previously approved the use of the term "4G" for Sprint's WiMAX and Verizon's LTE networks, he said -- though not for T-Mobile's HSPA+ network.
ITU's PR department ignored that approval in its recent statement about how future wireless technologies would be measured, the representative said. ITU representatives were not immediately available for comment.
"I'm not getting into a technical debate," said Jeffrey Nelson, spokesman for Verizon Wireless. "Consumers will quickly realize that there's really a difference between the capabilities of various wireless data networks. All '4G' is not the same."
And that's what's so difficult. The term 4G has become meaningless and confusing as hell for wireless customers.
For instance, T-Mobile's 4G network, which is technically 3G, will have speeds that are at least equal to -- and possibly faster -- than Verizon's 4G-LTE network at launch. At the same time, AT&T's 3G network, which is also being scaled up like T-Mobile's, is not being labeled "4G."
That's why some industry experts predict that the term "4G" will soon vanish.
"The labeling of wireless broadband based on technical jargon is likely to fade away in 2011," said Dan Hays, partner at industry consultancy PRTM. "That will be good news for the consumer. Comparing carriers based on their network coverage and speed will give them more facts to make more informed decisions."
Hays expects that independent researchers -- or the Federal Communications Commission -- will step in next year to perform speed and coverage tests.
Meanwhile, don't expect anyone to hold the carriers' feet to the fire.
"Historically, ITU's classification system has not held a great degree of water and has not been used to enforce branding," Hays said. "Everyone started off declaring themselves to be 4G long before the official decision on labeling was made. The ITU was three to four years too late to make an meaningful impact on the industry's use of the term."
http://money.cnn.com/2010/12/01/technology/4g_myth/index.htm

34 comments:

  1. This is really funny...even this so called 9ja 3.5G networks,can barely make 800kbs, yet it's called 3.5G,all of them be liars..they forgot the humble mercies have got intellectuals amongst them, who know the actual differences between this things!!!

    ReplyDelete
  2. Hey just wanted to give you a quick heads up. The words in your content seem to be running off the
    screen in Ie. I'm not sure if this is a formatting issue or something to do with internet browser compatibility but I thought I'd post to let you know.
    The layout look great though! Hope you get the problem fixed soon.

    Many thanks

    My page: iphone 5 leaked

    ReplyDelete
  3. Appreciate the recommendation. Will try it out.


    Here is my weblog; kitchen in northern virginia

    ReplyDelete
  4. It's easy to get lost in the jargon, I know I did, but what it equates to essentially is much less energy spent heating your home and thus an electricity bill less than half of what you'd be paying without the
    pumps. As indoor air pollution does not greatly affect us here
    in the US, most are unaware of the problem in general, let alone its devastating side effects and
    potential to have negative effects on the globe as a whole.
    Unlike wood stoves and fireplaces, pellet stoves burn small,
    dried, compressed pellets made from biomass products, such as sawdust, wood shavings,
    corn, and cherry pits. Greenhouse gas emissions from power plants and vehicular combustions have caused damage to the Earth's atmosphere and altered our present day climate.

    Also visit my webpage :: article-collection.info

    ReplyDelete
  5. Promise rings are sometimes also referred to purity rings,
    which can be given to a child by a parent or exchanged between couple to give your word
    on abstaining from sexual activity until marriage. What this type
    of ring symbolizes is that the couple agrees to not have romantic
    relationships with others, and later as their relationship grows
    and develops, the plan is to move to an actual engagement ring.
    The glitter, its sheer value and also the aura it radiates has
    gripped us all.

    Here is my page - Promise Rings Nordstroms

    ReplyDelete
  6. Ginger is one other spice which improves the fat loss mechanism.
    Even when your body is sitting still your body burns calories in order to function.
    While you read this, the cells of your body are busy creating ATP with every breath you take and storing it.
    Don't miss out on this essential exercise benefit, and reduce your risk of metabolic disorders such as diabetes at the same time.

    My website Fat burning breakfast foods

    ReplyDelete
  7. are usually mens tungsten rings plain looking gold rings with a shiny finish or more recently, platinum or white gold type rings.

    Titanium was a metal first used in the aerospace
    industry because of its ability to withstand high temperatures.
    For engraving ideas for birthstone and pre engagement promise rings, you could start with what prompted the giving of engraved promise rings.


    My web blog ... promise rings for couples

    ReplyDelete
  8. When you put money into handcrafted silver jewellery, you might be not
    merely acquiring a piece you can treasure, but one
    that may be likely to become an heirloom for long term generations.

    So you may think they are not suitable for
    the engagement rings or the wedding rings. There is general agreement that a major leap forward in the history of friendship rings occurred in
    late seventeenth and early eighteenth century Ireland in the Galway Bay area of Western Ireland, and in particular around Claddagh and
    nearby fishing villages.

    Also visit my blog post web page

    ReplyDelete
  9. Am I the only one out there who thinks Apple could really care less about the moral and spiritual issues behind pornography.
    They are usually given with the intent of
    changing into engaged at some purpose within the future.

    In a bold, albeit somewhat of a shallow and pedantic move, Apple has implemented Christian i - Phone app
    developer Island Wall Entertainment's Purity Ring Application, "in an attempt to engage with today's youth using new mediums.



    My web page - homepage

    ReplyDelete
  10. Women, if a man gives you a promise ring, be cautious.
    So you may think they are not suitable for the engagement rings or the wedding rings.
    Therefore you can go for detailed and eloquent designs of band to surprise your lady with.


    my blog post - promise rings for him and her

    ReplyDelete
  11. They also offer great after sales services that will keep you going back
    every time a jewelry emergency arises. For more information on birthstone and pre engagement promise
    rings, engraved promise rings or other jewelry, visit. You not simply possess a choice
    of your a lot more up-market brands but you also hold the alternative
    of going for inexpensive variations that happen to be as
    pleasing on the eye and as practical and reliable.

    Have a look at my weblog; promise rings video :: europk.ro ::

    ReplyDelete
  12. Women's Fat Burning Tips #3: Exercise in the Morning. You'll have a very hard time spotting anybody who's doing short fast cardio, also known as burst training, interval training and HIIT (high intensity interval training). One study in the American Journal of Epidemiology reported that subjects sleeping five hours or less per night were one-third more likely to gain 30-plus pounds over the 16-year study than those who slept seven hours or longer per night. Crunches and sit-ups will also not enable you to lose weight.

    my site; Best Fat Burning Foods

    ReplyDelete
  13. are usually mens tungsten rings plain looking gold rings with a shiny finish
    or more recently, platinum or white gold type rings.
    Having personal contacts with the jeweler is extremely important in case you need to resize or
    modify the ring. But there is only one generation that has
    a distinct ring of their own - the baby boomers.

    Here is my site ... promise rings vancouver

    ReplyDelete
  14. Apply the scrub in your brush or cloth, and massage the skin gently in circles.
    Honey - Washing see your face with honey or using a honey mask every day is able to keep uncontrollable acne at bay.
    If items are drying out your epidermis your oil production can increase while the skin tries to create balance.

    Examine your lifetime and see how you may make a change.

    my homepage - acne under lip

    ReplyDelete
  15. Quality: rings are everyday wear just like charm bracelets or gold
    pendants hence you must choose something durable.
    The only day that is more exciting than that is when she chooses the ring that signifies mutual
    love for a lifetime ' his and hers wedding rings that perfectly match in every facet and detail. Birthstone rings are excellent choices for pre engagement promise rings but you don't need to select a ring with their birthstone only.


    Here is my web-site: website - -

    ReplyDelete
  16. One of the most frequent would be diamonds, specially in rings which might be meant to
    symbolize enjoy considering they may be so long lasting. Shell cameos are
    carved from a single piece of shell. A blue-white diamond appears quite unique and distinctive, but actually, this style of
    diamond is of lesser high quality ' though the jeweler will try to generate you're thinking that you happen to be getting something exclusive.


    Here is my homepage ... promise rings joy jewelers

    ReplyDelete
  17. Since you want a PC clock gadget anyway, you will want to find
    one which has other options as well. Our entire bodies are made up of proteins carbohydrates and fats and more importantly water.
    Niacinamide is often a normal element and is a form
    of supplement B. Now, one teaspoon of sugar equals four grams of sugar.


    Also visit my page: clearlight acne

    ReplyDelete
  18. Following you have your songs lyrics or poems outlined, attempt taking
    part in with all the phrases to produce meaningful
    on your romantic relationship. You will discover a number of ornaments
    that fascinate everyone like necklaces, bracelets, watches, scarves, rings,
    handbags, brooches, belts and clips. It's beneficial to glimpse for a business which has been in enterprise for decades, and that has been offering on the web for a minimum of five many years.

    Here is my webpage promise rings vs engagement rings

    ReplyDelete
  19. Following you have your songs lyrics or poems
    outlined, attempt taking part in with all the phrases to produce meaningful on your romantic relationship.

    You will discover a number of ornaments that fascinate everyone like necklaces, bracelets, watches, scarves, rings, handbags, brooches, belts and clips.

    It's beneficial to glimpse for a business which has been in enterprise for decades, and that has been offering on the web for a minimum of five many years.

    My web-site; promise rings vs engagement rings

    ReplyDelete
  20. Baking soda remedy does not work properly for every form of
    skin. Intermittent administration (taking Accutane just one week a
    month) appears to work less well, producing insufficient recent results for more than half of
    the patients studied. The site may consider taking moment
    in time for you to take away those acne stretchmarks out of your respective nose in the event you end up restoring this program complete
    with pure ingredients. Sometimes people think "more is better"
    in terms of skin cleansing and may scrub excessively.


    Look at my web page acne jeans sale :: www.blazingarticle.com :
    :

    ReplyDelete
  21. However, small diamonds placed in a setting of yellow or
    white gold are quite common as promise rings for those who can afford them.

    It's just up to you what type of rings you want to gift your loved one. Referring with a diamond as a blue-white diamond is such a scam.

    Here is my site ... promise rings girlfriend

    ReplyDelete
  22. Am I the only one out there who thinks Apple could really care less about
    the moral and spiritual issues behind pornography.

    Even so, select cautiously in accordance with
    preference and spending budget. You do not
    need to settle for "almost great enough.

    Feel free to surf to my site; web page

    ReplyDelete
  23. Cultured pearls of all types may be found in jewelry shops worldwide.
    Promise rings are available in a spread of designs and center
    stones. As emerald is an expensive gem they usually come
    in shapes that help in retaining maximum weight
    from raw stone.

    My page :: promise rings how to wear - -

    ReplyDelete
  24. However, modern times demand a new look at why we give or possess the diamond ring.

    After the engagement, the ring is usually switched to the right hand.
    The assortment of steel options together with rare metal and sterling silver allow for some selections at incredibly economical charges.


    Also visit my blog - promise rings for her

    ReplyDelete
  25. Designs array from designs that can serve as both equally diamond engagement
    rings and pre-engagement diamond promise rings as well as distinctive ring designs.
    There are many online stores that provide you a wide variety of rings of
    unique designs that are perfect for the minor promises.
    Some may have one diamond with a different band style and
    form, while others may have a larger diamond with other smaller diamonds surrounding the bigger one.



    Visit my blog post; webpage

    ReplyDelete
  26. A gorgeous alternative to the traditional engagement rings, each of the stones in the three-stone ones stands for
    the different stages a relationship goes through - the past, the present and the future.
    Promise rings start at $59 and Engagement rings start at about
    $98 and go to $1998. Regardless of your personalized sensation on entire body piercings,
    know that you can be discriminated in opposition to or viewed
    in an unfavorable gentle by some persons only credited to your body piercings.


    My webpage :: promise rings walmart

    ReplyDelete
  27. Even the less overtly dangerous solutions get their drawbacks; glycolic
    compounds are associated with organ toxicity, antibiotics eliminate good bacteria and make resistance with
    time, and birth control method pills bring
    their own set of concerns and unwanted effects. For the first week, wash the face only
    at night with an extremely, very, gentle cleanser.

    Most suffers of acne possess a challenge on how to get rid of acne and pimples.

    Exfoliating clears pores and instead gives off the surface of
    your skin layer feeling smooth and healthy.


    Also visit my web page acne scar treatment

    ReplyDelete
  28. At $20 it is a really good deal and comes in a ton of shades.

    I usually remove my make-up right when I get home and know I'm not returning out - just so my pores don't clog.
    We believed as adults past our twenties we were now beyond the danger zone.
    Having a face brimming with acne is incredibly annoying
    to one's appearance, specifically in women.

    Here is my webpage :: acne scar laser treatment

    ReplyDelete
  29. Some people report slight feelings of tingling, itching, or burning
    after they apply baking soda with their face, but for most, it is not enough to
    cause discomfort. However being emotionally upset can trigger the
    discharge of stress hormones which signal our bodies's preparation for confrontation or perhaps the removal through the situation. If you have problems with acne and so are looking for remedy option that actually works, look no further than the Obagi acne kit. Sometimes people think "more is better" with regards to skin cleansing and may scrub excessively.

    Look at my homepage ... symptoms of acne

    ReplyDelete
  30. And if it's your marriage you desire to glance, as beautiful as hardly ever before. Dark Blue - lovable, very happy, romantic, passionate. These designs are each bit as exotic and also a great deal a lot more economical than a matched strand.

    Feel free to surf to my web blog: promise ring 930 club ()

    ReplyDelete
  31. Small children only pick a specific watch that caters
    to their attraction at that specific stage of time. The tradition of exchanging rings
    and them being worn by both men and women as symbol
    of marriage came about only toward the twentieth
    century. Promise rings are an excellent tool for young couples who are intent on being exclusive and monogamous with one another.


    Also visit my page: promise rings tiffany evans

    ReplyDelete
  32. Quality: rings are everyday wear just like charm bracelets or gold
    pendants hence you must choose something durable.
    Ultimately, a promise ring is not about hard and fast rules,
    but about finding rings that you are both comfortable with.
    The glitter, its sheer value and also the aura it radiates
    has gripped us all.

    Here is my page :: web page

    ReplyDelete
  33. However, small diamonds placed in a setting of yellow or white
    gold are quite common as promise rings for those who
    can afford them. This may perhaps go with no stating, but usually do not confuse
    commercially manufactured jewelry with handcrafted silver jewellery.

    It's beneficial to glimpse for a business which has been in enterprise for decades, and that has been offering on the web for a minimum of five many years.

    Here is my site; website

    ReplyDelete
  34. Do only a FEW sets of inner and outer thigh routines. This doesn't mean that panaerobics is a substitute for traditional strength training; it's
    still a cardio-centric modality. Other fat burning foods include high fiber foods, low
    fat or fat free dairy products, hot peppers, cinnamon and garlic.

    So, you can increase the amount of calories you burn by having more muscle.


    my website - top ten fat burning foods

    ReplyDelete